The court considers that neither the court of first instance nor the Court of Las Palmas carried out an “exhaustive investigation” before filing the case. “degrading treatment” is prohibited by Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Two magistrates, César Tolosa and Enrique Arnaldo, have voted against the sentence. Junts maintains that Sánchez and Aragonès agreed on early elections to prevent Puigdemont's candidacy.