Trial underway, the lawyer discovers the sentence has already been written. The criminal chamber of Florence reported the case.

The defender asked for the panel to abstain. The decision was authorized by the president of the Court Marilena Rizzo. The complaint lasts Criminal Chamber of Florence: "We take note of the explanations of the college which in the face of the legitimate complaints... stated it was "a mere draft, susceptible to being remodulated after the intervention of the parties". But "it seems clear that a decision had in fact already been taken without first having listened to the defense arguments"