Scotland-France (16-20): why the referee refused the Scots' try to win. The XV of France won at the end of the suspense in Edinburgh this Saturday afternoon.

After Australian referee Nic Berry refused to agree to a video refereeing sequence. For almost 5 minutes, Nic Berry studies the image in which the ball first lands on a stud before possibly sliding down the line. “The rule works for us,” says Vincent Clerc, consultant for France 2. ‘The referee decided on the pitch that there was no try and he has no clear image to change his mind’