The Juvenile Court of Milan, as part of the proceeding on the complaint lodged by Eitan's maternal grandparents against the appointment of paternal aunt Aya as legal guardian, has decided to appoint a foreign professional as "guardian" in "replacement" of the aunt " to both families of origin ", keeping" the child placed with the aunt ". This was communicated by the president of the Juvenile Court, Maria Carla Gatto, clarifying that the decision was taken due to "the very high level of conflict, which occurred after the initial appointment of the guardian" which "made it necessary to identify a third party".
"The Milan Juvenile Court - explains President Gatto - at the outcome of the hearing on 9 December 2021 concerning the complaint against the provision of the tutelary judge of Pavia, proposed by the maternal grandparents of the minor Eitan, appointed as guardian of the latter, in place of the paternal aunt, a professional extraneous to both families of origin, keeping the child placed with the aunt ".
"The very high conflict - clarifies the magistrate - which occurred after the initial appointment of the guardian, made it necessary to identify a third party, given that the parental dispute that arose undoubtedly contributes to complicating any personal, relational, economic and educational choice that it will have to be assumed in the primary interest of the child, already so dramatically marked by the tragic personal experiences ".
"In the interest of the child, we welcome the removal of Aya Biran as a guardian in favor of a third party, as had been requested from the beginning by her maternal grandparents". So the lawyers Sara Carsaniga and Paolo Polizzi,
lawyers of Shmuel Peleg and Esther Cohen, the maternal grandparents of Eitan
, a 6-year-old child who survived the Mottarone tragedy and at the center of a dispute between two family branches, comment on the decision of the Court for minors of Milan to appoint, following the complaint presented by the same lawyers, a third-party professional, a lawyer from Monza, as legal guardian of the child in place of the aunt.
On December 9, a hearing was held before the Milan Juvenile Court in which the complaint presented by Eitan's maternal grandparents against the appointment of paternal aunt Aya Biran as legal guardian was discussed. Appointment established at the end of last May by the Turin Court and then confirmed by a Pavia judge in August. After the discussion of the lawyers of the two family branches, the judges reserved their decision and they did so today. The proceedings, before the Juvenile Court and centered on a series of questions posed by the grandparents' lawyers (who also contested the alleged falsity of the appointment report based on a doctor's document) began last October 22 with a first hearing. Among other things, the paternal aunt in recent months has already submitted a request to the Court foradoption of the child, as did, among other things, the aunt of the child's maternal branch. The procedure on the adoption is autonomous and goes on and is different from the one on the appointment of the guardian who must at this stage serve the interests, on all fronts, of the minor. Eitan returned to Italy on 3 December after the sentence of the Supreme Court of Tel Aviv which recognized, like the two previous decisions, the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, recipient of a warrant arrest following the investigations of the Pavia prosecutors also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and of his grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.also the aunt of the child's maternal branch. The procedure on the adoption is autonomous and goes on and is different from the one on the appointment of the guardian who must at this stage serve the interests, on all fronts, of the minor. Eitan returned to Italy on 3 December after the sentence of the Supreme Court of Tel Aviv which recognized, like the two previous decisions, the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, recipient of a warrant arrest following the investigations of the Pavia prosecutors also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and of his grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.also the aunt of the child's maternal branch. The procedure on the adoption is autonomous and goes on and is different from the one on the appointment of the guardian who must at this stage serve the interests, on all fronts, of the minor. Eitan returned to Italy on 3 December after the sentence of the Supreme Court of Tel Aviv which recognized, like the two previous decisions, the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, recipient of a warrant arrest following the investigations of the Pavia prosecutors also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and of his grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.adoption is autonomous and goes on and is different from that on the appointment of the guardian who has to make the interests, on all fronts, of the minor at this stage. Eitan returned to Italy on 3 December after the sentence of the Supreme Court of Tel Aviv which recognized, like the two previous decisions, the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, recipient of a warrant arrest following the investigations of the Pavia prosecutors also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and of his grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.adoption is autonomous and goes on and is different from that on the appointment of the guardian who has to make the interests, on all fronts, of the minor at this stage. Eitan returned to Italy on 3 December after the sentence of the Supreme Court of Tel Aviv which recognized, like the two previous decisions, the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, recipient of a warrant arrest following the investigations of the Pavia prosecutors also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and his grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, the recipient of an arrest warrant following the investigations of the public prosecutors from Pavia also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and of her grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.the international abduction, on 11 September last, of the child by his grandfather Shmuel Peleg, the recipient of an arrest warrant following the investigations of the public prosecutors from Pavia also against the alleged accomplice Gabriel Alon Abutbul, arrested in Cyprus and awaiting extradition, and of her grandmother Esther Cohen, under investigation in competition for the kidnapping.
