The new comedy directed by Édouard Baer was released this Wednesday, January 26.
Adieu Paris
brings together a cast that only the actor could bring together: Benoît Poelvoorde, Pierre Arditi, François Damiens, Bernard Le Coq, Jackie Berroyer, Bernard Murat, Daniel Prévost and Jean-François Stévenin. These eight sit down at the Closerie des Lilas and remake the world. A film about friendship and the passage of time, which
Le Figaro
describes as a
“bittersweet comedy”
, and the portrait
of “a disappearing generation”
. Bertrand de Saint Vincent believes that
“Édouard Baer signs with elegance the burial of a life of old bachelors, of an era, of a civilization: that of the white male, in love with words. (...) We get out of this
Farewell to Paris
, as disenchanted as it is enchanted.
Read alsoOur review of
Adieu Paris
, by Édouard Baer: lights out
In the same vein,
Les Échos
evokes a film
“in the flavor of a last drink before closing or of a party that evaporates in the early morning”.
Adrien Gombaud particularly appreciated Édouard Baer's production,
"a lively, fluid story that is both funny... and strangely sad".
Benoît Poelvoorde's performance is also hailed.
"Explosive, endearing, heartbreaking, [he] plays one of his great roles: his own."
For
La Voix du Nord
,
Adieu Paris
is
“in the image of Édouard Baer. Funny, often. Annoying, sometimes."
Christophe Caron recognizes that
"we end up being touched by the cruel melancholy expressed, reluctantly, by these damaged and playful ghosts who no longer know if they are truly friends."
An indulgence that
Première
does not have for this
“gastronomic and ruminative closed door”.
The feature film
“gets lost, gets scattered, despite some great ideas. (...) We smile, while saying to ourselves that Baer has not yet produced the great Cassavetian work, à la
Husbands
(unleashed, dead drunk, freed from all conventions), which he undoubtedly has in him.
Read alsoÉdouard Baer: "
Theatre is the exact opposite of digital
"
The deep nostalgia of Edouard Baer's sixth film only very moderately convinced
Liberation
. "
Although visibly nostalgic, Édouard Baer does not consider these specimens to be cruelty-free, emphasizing both the ridiculousness of what they represent and their general mediocrity, while remaining one or two trains behind the times. He reserves his benevolence for a handful of more endearing characters who bustle behind the scenes and gradually short-circuit the plot, a way for the film to show a Dada disinterest in the circle it has set up
”, writes Élisabeth Franck Dumas.
"In short, nothing, a lot of nothing, wanted and assumed as such, mounted in a whipped cream that aims toraise this assembly to the rank of beautiful losers without quite succeeding.
Farewell Paris
, we don't really know (so that was it, Paris?) but fair winds, yes.
Read alsoFriendship, politics, his new film … The confidences of Édouard Baer, the fake dilettante
Le Monde
perceives a
“casual film”
.
Jacques Mandelbaum wonders.
“
Adieu Paris
would it go too far in the fuzzy deconstructivist tendency of Édouard Baer?
We are entitled to ask the question as it seems difficult to report the subject and to grasp the spirit.
Adieu Paris
is a closed session that brings together eight old glories at La Closerie des Lilas, on the occasion of the deliberation of a worldly jury which awards a prize to a person who has done nothing all year.
From which it follows almost nothing, if not the pleasure of seeing actors that we love thus united.
The impression, in a word, that it is all the same the work that here, quite stupidly, was lacking.
funny and annoying
La Croix
speaks of a
"pochade of pochtrons turns into a squeaky, bittersweet comedy, of
'old idiots'
who cling to the banister, review the attacks of age, the worries of money, on background of noisy rantings, while philosophizing in the small week.
Not enough to convince the Catholic daily.
“It drags on, it's uneven like any meal, with its hollows and its ups and downs, a little heavy like a banquet that's too long, the sauce doesn't really take.
Even the good words, which we are so fond of at Édouard Baer, become pasty at times.