The Limited Times

Now you can see non-English news...

'The weapon of deception': a somewhat old story about the disinformation with which Hitler choked

2022-05-20T03:57:29.496Z


The romantic melodrama is very present in a film in which the eternal capacity of British cinema to stamp great historical episodes on the screen shines


The spies are at the same time writers of everyday life and artists of their own creation.

They concoct, invent, recreate, lie, live the truth of their own trollas and finally achieve their goals through a continuous representation that occupies them 24 hours a day.

More information

Spies in Huelva: the man who never existed

For this reason, in the magnificent

Three Days of the Condor

, the CIA had an entire department of librarians at the service of the institution, experts in history who tried to foresee future reality through the analysis of fictions from the present and the past.

And that is why, in the midst of World War II, in 1943, a group of British Army analysts, experts in deception operations, came up with the most exciting of fictional stories, in order to try to convince the Nazis of that the allies were going to invade Greece instead of Sicily.

An almost unlikely war strategy, which they called Operation Minced Meat, which the cinema already dealt with in the classic

The Man Who Never Was,

directed by Ronald Neame in 1956, based on a book published by one of the perpetrators of the great hoax, Ewen Montagu, and now joined

by The Weapon of Deception,

directed by John Madden, and based on a relatively recent book, published in 2010 by Ben Macintyre, historian and journalist for

The Times

, which offers new details that Montagu could not determine at the time due to the pact of certain silence he had with the secret services.

With a very uneven career, Madden, director of

Shakespeare in Love

, never stood out for his creative details and here he once again demonstrates that, at most, he can be a good story illustrator if the script he starts from is solid and attractive.

That was the case of the surprising winner of the Oscar for best film about the loves of the playwright;

The

Debt

(2010), also in the spy subgenre;

and, in a certain sense, that of

El Arma del Deceit,

in which, yes, the real event and what is being told always remains at a much higher level than the way in which it is being told.

Along with the espionage, the romantic melodrama is very present in a production with a somewhat old-fashioned aura, but with that eternal capacity of British cinema to stamp great historical episodes on the screen.

Hence, together with the presence of a handful of actors and actresses from the series, the film has a visual and production aspect similar to any of the episodes of

The Crown

;

here, without the queen, although with Winston Churchill, who this time plays the great theater actor Simon Russell Beale.

Academic and relatively vigorous, but never as exciting as the great story it describes inside,

El Arma del Deceit

has for the Spanish viewer the added incentive of the fundamental role of our country in perhaps the best episode in the history of disinformation, since The coast of Huelva was chosen to leave the false corpse with the false papers that were supposed to deceive the Germans.

The neutrality of Spain, its fascist network and good relations with the Nazis offered the perfect conditions for a diverse group of Spaniards to collaborate in the mess without knowing it, which leads to the interpretive presence of, among others, Pedro Casablanc and Javier Godino .

The patience, thoroughness and artistry once displayed by the perpetrators of World War II's most famous hoax remain superior to any film.

His unusual inventiveness and his unsurpassed representation are unparalleled.

The artists, at least for this time, were them, because even Churchill's last sentence seems insurmountable: "They have swallowed all the minced meat."

The weapon of deception

Direction:

John Madden.

Cast:

Colin Firth, Matthew Macfadyen, Kelly MacDonald, Penelope Wilton.

Genre:

espionage.

United Kingdom, 2021.

Duration:

128 minutes.

Premiere: May 20.

Exclusive content for subscribers

read without limits

subscribe

I'm already a subscriber

Source: elparis

All life articles on 2022-05-20

You may like

Trends 24h

Life/Entertain 2024-03-28T17:17:20.523Z

Latest

© Communities 2019 - Privacy

The information on this site is from external sources that are not under our control.
The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation or endorse the views expressed within them.