Zhongdasheng involved in the police case, the police officer said on the scene that he was tripped to the court and said that the accused was not found guilty.

Social News

Written by: Lin Leer

2020-07-06 17:47

A male student of CUHK was accused of overthrowing a riot police officer holding a shield while the police intercepted a woman on the night of the Tsuen Kwai Tsing parade on August 25 last year. He earlier denied that the assault police had been tried. Magistrate Liu Qiyun said at the West Kowloon Magistrates' Court (6th) that the police officer claimed to have tripped at the scene, but the court accused the defendant of pushing the shield against his hand, and he was pushed down. Liu Guan believed that the two actions were completely different, and the video did not show the defendant impacting the defense line or pushing the shield. Due to the suspicion of the police officer, the court ruled that the defendant was not guilty.

The defendant claimed that the film was important for such cases

The defendant, Zhu Jiale (21 years old), is a CUHK student. He was accused of attacking police officer Chen Jinxiang outside the HKT1010 shop at the junction of Tsuen Wan Market Street and Zhong An Street on August 25 last year. He said he was grateful after the court appearance, referring to the help of many people, and said: "I know that this is a difficult time, and I hope that some friends who have a case will have more rest." He continued, video recording is very important for such cases. I urge everyone to check whether the mobile phone contains the fragments of the case, and transfer it to a reliable person such as a lawyer.

The official pointed out that the film did not see the push shield

Police officer Chen Jinxiang earlier stated that he had no intention to gamble on the defendant to push the shield, but felt that the other party exerted force on the shield with his left palm, so he fell out of balance and fell back. Then the same robe pulled the defendant into the defense line.

Liu Guanjin analyzed that if the situation is true, there should be a clear distance between the defendant and the shield, but the video involved in the case shows no distance.

The defendant accused Chen himself of falling

According to the recorded transcript, the defendant claimed at the scene that Chen fell himself, and Chen said: "You slap me! You slap me!" Liu Guan said, "Slap" means that the lower limb accidentally touched a hard object, rope, etc., and the body was pushed by the hand It is completely related to another part, emphasizing that it should not confuse the two. If Chen feels that the opponent is pushing, the natural reaction should be to say that he was pushed, not to be pushed.

The defendant never hit the police line of defense

Liu Guan also pointed out that most of the time in the film showed that the defendant held up his mobile phone and did not get close to the police. Although he questioned the policeman's method of intercepting a woman, he never hit the police line of defense. The court slow-moved the video and found that the police's actions and reactions were in line with the defense's argument that the police had brought the defendant's body to the shield while pulling the defendant into the line of defense.

Because Chen’s testimony was in doubt, and the video reflected the timeliness and continuity of the actions of the individuals in the case, it was also impossible to affirm the prosecution’s accusation, and the court ruled that the defendant was not guilty.

Case number: WKCC3484/2019

Fugitive Offenders｜Attack on the police woman was withdrawn from the defense

Superintendent of Water Supplies Department was arrested for tripping, was arrested and retired

Fugitive Offenders｜17-year-old boy involved in an umbrella off-duty police offense, accused the police officer’s confession of exaggeration

Fugitive Offenders｜Survey of police students involved in arrest after face arrest, accused Fang Zheng of confession of conviction

Assault Court for Assaulting Police Fugitives Ordinance