Every day more horror is revealed from "Tully's Nursery" in Ramla • When they meet the parents from Carmel Meuda's kindergarten, there is a sense of partnership between them • "My son hides in the shower if someone raises his voice", says Maor, one of Ramla's parents • "This is how he behaves A battered child, "answers Yossi, one of Rosh HaAyin's parents

• "I do not like 'the teacher's, this is the life of your children", the parents from Tully's nursery and Carmel's kindergarten

  Photo: 

  Tzachi Miriam

"Watching the videos reveals a picture of violence, which was used against toddlers on numerous occasions. This is not a one-time incident or a stumble, but a systematic violence, which was used as a routine and included beatings to the head, slaps, throwing objects, urgency, slamming one of the toddlers' head on the wall. "Throwing toddlers at mattresses and throwing food on the floor so that they can eat from it. The heart is sour in the face of the violence used against the helpless, who could not defend themselves at all."

(Judge Zohar Divon Segal, August 3, during the extension of the detention of the assistants and the principal of "Tully's Nursery" in Ramla, who are suspected of attacking the helpless)

Many tears flowed in the charged and painful meeting between the parents of the children from Carmel Meoda's kindergarten in Rosh HaAyin and the parents of the children from Tully Ramla's nursery, which made headlines a week ago, after it also revealed alleged atrocities. Eight young men, who have become brothers in trouble, following an agonizing and debilitating partnership of fate. Like soldiers fighting on the battlefield, so they fight for the fate of their children.

Everyone had a look in their eyes. Among Ramle's parents this was an expression of pain, seeking solace. Despair was seen in the eyes of the parents of Rosh HaAyin. They feel that a year of intense activity - in demonstrations, in Knesset committees, on social networks - has not led to a significant change in the state's attitude towards private kindergarten children.

"I understand you, but we do not have an optimistic message for you," explains Nicole Daniel, whose two children, aged 3 and 2, are opening the indictment against Meuda. "The coming year is going to be very difficult for you. There will be pangs of conscience, anxiety, uncertainty and a lot of pain. I am not the same person I used to be.

"The frustration is huge. We took thousands of people to demonstrations, met with politicians and lived the trauma 24 hours a day. And where are we today? In the same place. Although there is a lot of awareness today, but there is no proper punishment, no supervision and no control."

Nicole's partner in the struggle, Yossi Hevra, whose 4-year-old daughter has been in a kindergarten for a year and a half, agrees. "We are abandoning the children in the country. A year ago we believed we would lead to legislative change, and it did not happen, although people's awareness has gone up. We have learned to live with what we went through, and any change for the better that shows children overcoming trauma is happiness and comfort."

A friend surprises the parents from Ramla when he reveals that he and Nicole recently considered retiring from the protest, but decided to stay following the new case. "You drew us back in. Maybe thanks to the combination of forces we will succeed in the mission."

As the days go by, more and more horror stories about toddler abuse are revealed. The investigation, led by Inspector Yaniv Amram of the Ramla police, shows that the staff in the kindergarten threw packs of wipes at the children until some of them fell to the ground, pushed them, pulled them by the hands, hit them on the head. Videos of security cameras in the kindergarten revealed that children were forcibly slapped on mattresses and chairs. One of the children was lying on the mattress with an assistant banging his head on her leg, another child was tied to a chair with a diaper.

So far, nine people have been arrested in the case, on suspicion of assaulting a helpless person: the garden owner, Little Bersi (39), and her husband Moshe (42), and the seven assistants - including Nirit Shweid (47), Ruhama Saad (38), Hani Nana Tzetshvili (50), Orly Shragani (37) and Inbar Donio (29), and two others aged 49 and 26. The Bercy couple are also suspected of failing to report the acts.

"Everyone recommended the garden"

The meeting with the parents takes place in a successful moshav, at the home of Bat-El Amin (28), the mother of a one-year-old and four-month-old toddler. From the large balcony you can see the high-rise of the artists' neighborhood in Ramla, where the garden is located. The open line of sight gave Bat-El a deceptive feeling that her daughter was within touching distance and therefore protected.

Beside Bat-El sits Maor Bitton (31), a two-year-old father who was in the daycare center, and a 5-year-old girl. And Reuven Ben Shimon (33), the father of a two-year-old and five-month-old toddler, who has been in the nursery since the age of seven months.

Bat-El's husband, Chen (29), passes quietly between them, serving coffee and plates with pastries and vegetables. From one of the rooms emanates the laughter of their toddler daughter, who unexpectedly bursts onto the balcony with her hands outstretched towards her mother. Bat-El hugs the toddler with the light curls, wrapping her body around her hands. Her eyes fill with tears. The girl slides with a smile from her mother's knees and returns to her father.

"She was born after a year and a half of fertility treatment," Bat-El says in a shaky voice, "I was so worried about her that we decided to put her in kindergarten only when she reached the age of one. But for economic reasons we did it when she was six months old, in September 2019." .

Weren't you afraid, in light of the Carmel Moeda affair, which was exposed two and a half months earlier?

Bat-El: "We were worried. A close friend recommended Tully's nursery to me, because she worked there three years ago, and I thought it was perfect because my mother-in-law lived in a building next to the garden, and I thought she could go there and pick up the girl if necessary. That the nursery will be revealed as a monster. "

Maor and Jenny, who live in the artists' neighborhood, had no doubt that their children would also go to Tully's nursery, although not far away there is a Naamat kindergarten, which costs less. "There was no question at all," says Maor, "everyone knew the garden and recommended it."

Jenny: "We were quiet, we did not believe that the Carmel affair would ever return here. Every morning I said to Ruhama the assistant thank you that she is there, because thanks to her I sleep well at night."

Reuven's son has been in kindergarten for almost two years. He and his wife, Etty (32), debated quite a bit before putting their only son there. "We knew Na'amat's garden was monitored by the state, but we were sure the nursery would be safer, because of the cameras."

Tully's nursing home was established in a private home about five years ago. The Bercy couple opened a nursery for children up to one year of age, a toddler complex up to two years old and an adult complex up to age 3. The photos that appear in the image video of the kindergarten show children sleeping peacefully, covered with colorful blankets. Other photos show new mattresses, a variety of toys and neat diaper corners. An illustration of a butterfly fluttering between the images, accompanied by soothing music, gives a feeling of peace and security.

Although the garden's Facebook account has been deleted, it can still be read in the link to it that "the place is provided with warm and loving care by experienced and experienced caregivers." Seven assistants worked at the nursing home, all currently detained.

Assistant Nirit Schweid was employed in the kindergarten, although a year and a half ago a case was opened against her by the police for violence against children, and it was still open at the time of her employment. The case was recently closed by the prosecution on the ground of innocence.

Have any of you noticed any early signs?

Bat-El: "In retrospect I can think of two signs. My daughter started walking two months ago and did it strangely, with both her hands behind her back. The family laughed and called her 'the commander'. Today I am afraid it is due to things she experienced in kindergarten. I have Dreams, in which her hands are tied behind her back.

"Plus, she recently started waking up screaming in the middle of the night. I thought it was because I moved her to a rollaway bed, but I guess she just had nightmares from kindergarten."

Maor: "Every time we gave my son and his sister Bamba, she ate from the bag, and he scattered the Bamba on the floor and ate from it. Sometimes he bent like a dog and bit Bamba like that. It started in the last six months, and still continues. We thought it was just a weird habit we should stop. "Now I suspect it came from the kindergarten. In recent days I remembered that he did not always like to enter the kindergarten and did not agree that I should transfer him to the assistants, but I admit that we did not suspect anything."

Reuben's son refused to enter the kindergarten almost every morning. "How come I did not see the signs?" He was tormented, "The boy would lie down on the hot sidewalk, and I could barely lift him. He would scream like crazy, sticking his nails in my hands until he left me with red marks.

"I thought maybe other kids were harassing him a bit because he was gentle, but I did not assume it was the staff. Every time I shared this with the assistants or Little, they said my son was spoiled, and that my delay with him entering the kindergarten made it difficult for him to break up.

"One day, a few months ago, I decided to drop him off at kindergarten and go. I stood in the distance and saw my son trying to follow me, crying. My heart crashed to pieces. The assistant came out immediately and took the child.

"Every time we asked him if everything was fine in kindergarten, he said yes or evaded. We did not worry because at home he was a happy child. I had the thought of asking to look at the security cameras, but I was afraid of being portrayed as a problematic father, and that because of me they would take revenge on the child."

Jenny: "I was also convinced that the girl was pampered when she did not want to enter kindergarten. I thought the girl had an anxiety of leaving."

Creepy sights

The atrocities in Tully's nursing home probably would not have been exposed if security cameras had not been stolen during the corona closure in April. Maor says that the kindergarten owner turned to one of the parents, who works as a camera technician, and asked him to install news.

"He put together eight cameras. Two in the yard, one in the entrance, two in the nursery, one in the nursery, one in the toddlers and one in the aisle between the rooms. When he checked the cameras' recording device, he was exposed to videos from the last month and a half. At that moment he called some parents. Good. "

Jenny: "The technician's wife called me. I came to them to see what it was about, and I was scared. I saw one of the assistants throw a child on a trampoline, and when he cried, she ignored him. Another assistant forcibly seated a child on a chair. In another video they saw the children sitting on Chairs in a circle, with no toys next to them, and not moving for a long time.

"Maor's son was one of the children who was seen sitting motionless. At one point he was bored, and he got down from the chair. The assistant sat him back and tied him to a seat in a Tetra diaper. After a few minutes she released him, and then tied him again."

Maor, did you watch the videos?

"Not in the one where my son appears. But I have seen others, in which the aides throw packages of wipes at the children and hit them in the head or back. That evening we went to the Ramla police and filed a complaint."

Reuben: "I saw my son get hit in the head helping. It's hard to describe how you feel in moments like this. I also saw how the help hit a child with a flip-flop in the head when she bursts out laughing, knocking a child a bottle of water on the forehead or hitting another child with a diaper."

Bat-El: "And what about the girl you helped make her a ponytail, and in the process throws a blow at her that made her burst into tears?"

As they describe the creepy sights, four parents from Carmel Meuda's kindergarten arrive at the house. First comes Nicole Daniel, 35, whose video of her eldest son lying face down on the ground and his hands tied behind his back for 40 minutes has become a symbol of the affair. Next to her sits Moriae Coalio, 33, whose 3-year-old son was born with a dysfunctional kidney. Despite his condition, it was alleged in the charges against Meuda, she pushed hard on the chair he was sitting on, until his stomach was crushed against the table. One day she stood him and Nicole's son cross-legged for 45 minutes, without allowing them to lean or lean on anything.

Behind them was Hila Stein, 31, whose 3-year-old son was lifted from the mattress by Meuda while he slept and was forcibly put on his feet. Yossi Hevra (30) is the only one whose 4-year-old daughter appears in the indictment in a different way. There is no evidence that she was abused during the 19 days documented by the security cameras, however in one of the videos she frees Nicole's son from the rope that tied his hands.

The indictment attributes to Meuda (26) the abuse and assault of the helpless 11 of the kindergarten children. Her trial is expected to open in September, after the parties' attempt to reach a settlement exploded about a month ago.

Her assistant, Liraz Natan, 32, whose trial began about three months ago, is accused of assaulting five of the children. She argues that the events described do not correspond to reality.

The eyes of the four parents from Ramla hang in the "old" group, the seven battles. Before he sat down, Yossi approached Maor and patted him lightly on the shoulder. They met three years ago, when Yossi started a Facebook group called "Damaged Dad Betar", which consists of fans of the Jerusalem football team.

Maor: "Yossi, what do you say? Should I see the video in which my son appears? I heard about it from several mothers."

Yossi: "It's better for you not to. It scratches your brain and will leave you etched in the head forever. From what I hear, it seems that your assistants have taken an example from Carmel ever since."

Nicole: "I recommend you see, you owe it to yourself. I saw my son tied to the floor, and I was not satisfied with a minute of watching. I saw to the end, how he lay on the floor with his hands tied, and I cried like crazy. To understand the children. We have to see what they experienced. "

Hila: "I also saw the videos from Carmel's kindergarten, even though my husband did not want to. It was important for me to see what the child went through, so that the professionals would know how to take care of him."

Maor: "Agree. When I see what my son did, it will give me the strength to get into the fight for justice. It is also the way to digest that these difficult things were part of my son's life."

Moriah's voice breaks and her tears trickle down to the black mask that covers her nose and mouth. "I saw the videos when I was in my ninth month. My husband refused, so I sat alone. I saw Carmel forcibly push my child to the table, and I crashed. She could hurt the only kidney he had."

Yossi: "Maor, you have been my friend for a long time, listen to me. Wait at least a year. Let time pass because the sights will turn you on."

Bat-El bursts into tears. She talks about her anxieties and asks her teacher if her son is in kindergarten today with cameras. Moriah, who is herself a kindergarten assistant, answers in the negative. "I have known the kindergarten teacher in his kindergarten for many years," her voice trembles, "her son was in the kindergarten where I work as an assistant."

Bat-El: "And your son is well?"

Moriah: "He underwent a fundamental change in the new kindergarten. He is happy, open, started talking. The kindergarten teacher manages to contain me and my anxieties. For all the nonsense I turn over and erupt. Sometimes she shouts for nothing. Every word of the staff can remind me of Carmel, and then I Looking for hidden motives. "

Jenny: "I do not understand, after all what saved your children is the cameras. Does not matter to you? I am now looking for a kindergarten with online cameras, so I can see the child all day."

Hila: "It's not always good. It's hard to lead a life when you look at a screen all day. You have to learn to let go a little."

Moriah: "Just so you know you're in the beginning. A year is not enough to overcome the anxieties. For me it has not passed, and I do not know if it will ever pass."

"The mind is still shattered"

A moment of silence ensues as Shabbat asks her parents if they are suffering from pangs of conscience. "I do not sleep at night," the tears choked her throat. "I moved the girl to our bed because I have no heart to leave her alone at night. Every hour I wake up and look at her. This week was the first time in several months that she slept quietly and did not wake up screaming."

Reuben: "How can you not feel guilty? After all, we did not see. I did not link things when my son suddenly burst into screams in the middle of the night. Now it calmed down. A few days ago I did him at an amusement park sex house. I sat him on an office chair with wheels, I gave him "Holding a rope on one side, and on the other I pulled it and twisted it. He laughed, but I cried inside. I suddenly realized that something as innocent as a rope could remind him of ties."

Jenny: "I had a regime of times and sleep, but in the last week everything has changed. There is no more clock. I have released. I have left work in the meantime, and I have not announced when I will return, even though I have only just returned from sick leave. The girl is with me all day. At noon we sleep together, hugged. She also gets everything she wants.

"I noticed that since we took her out of kindergarten, she stopped crying at night and progressed greatly in speech. On the other hand, I found out she became violent. Sometimes she beats her big brother. I sent a happy and calm girl to kindergarten, and she came back broken."

Maor: "We still keep boundaries so as not to change the child's routine. We are constantly checking that he is not eating from the floor. I personally have a strange feeling of disconnection. It is as if my body is moving around at home, but my head is somewhere else."

The parents from Ramla listen to the frustration of their tragedy friends and nod in understanding. Yossi says that in the first days, after learning about the atrocities in Meuda's kindergarten, he had a hard time dealing with the night of emotions. "My rage and frustration mingled with the pain and the desire to protect the girl. Like something is constantly hovering over your head, and you are never connected, just to the girl.

"With us, too, all boundaries have been breached since the incident. There are no hours, and the children do what they want. It is a natural reaction of a parent, who wants to make up for what his child went through. In those days I did not really cope, nor could I. My soul is still shattered."

Moria cries again. "I could not get myself out of bed. Today I look at my little daughter, who is now a year old, and ask myself who raised her. I was not there, at home. I hovered. Since Carmelain I have no faith in humans."

Bat-El: "How can I trust someone now?"

Moriah: "Everyone is suspicious in my eyes. I can no longer see the good in people. When I stand in front of me taking care of children, I see a monster. It's awful, because I also helped."

Yossi: "I found that I could not trust anyone, sometimes not even family members. My circle of friends also changed. I no longer have a common language with people who did not go through what we experienced. Most of the friends close to me today are people whose children have been abused. "I met on our Facebook page and in demonstrations."

Nicole: "I sat at home for nine months and did not go to work. I had nothing on my mind except Carmel. I almost crushed the family. My husband asked me to stop seeing only my pain, the fracture, the thought that every morning I put my children in the hands of a monster. He. He wanted me to see the children first.

"What encourages me today is that the little boy got through it relatively easily, because he was a year old. Occasionally he is still startled when someone makes a quick movement and shrinks in place as if trying to dodge a blow.

"The big one is improving, he's up and once down. On the one hand he laughs, talks, is happy, but there are also the hard moments, like yesterday, when we were with the psychologist. He played with her in the doll and asked if the doll could sit. The psychologist told him yes, And he kicked the doll and that's how he sat it down.

"At that moment I could not breathe. I asked him why he did it, and he answered me innocently: 'I just wanted the doll to sit.' He did not even understand what I wanted from him. Apparently that is how he was taught in Carmel's garden."

Hila: "I believe our innocence and that of the children died when the affair began. Every time we turned up the volume on TV, my son hid under the couch. The day after I told him there was no more Carmel and he would not see her again, he seemed to unload everything he had accumulated. To a violent child, he can hit me in the head, something he never did before.

"In recent months he has been in emotional therapy, and is slowly calming down. He is talkative and smiling, but not willing to talk about Carmel. When I ask him what he went through in kindergarten, he is silent."

Maor: "My son hides in the shower if someone raises his voice or when the music is a little loud."

Yossi: "That's how beaten children behave."

"Carmel lives here"

Nicole says that a few months ago, when she came to pick up her son from kindergarten, the assistant said that he hit her.

"It made me sad. I sat him in the car and could not drive. I turned to him and asked if any of the garden staff had hit him. I listed all the names, and he answered in the negative. I simply asked if anyone else hit him, and he replied: 'Yes, Carmel.' "I froze. This is the first time he has said her name since. I explained to him that she would never hurt him again."

Yossi: "The children remember very well. My daughter was relatively big, a little over 3, and to this day she says that 'Carmel and Liraz are bad.' She often asked me, 'Why did you send me to their kindergarten?'. For the first time I broke down and told her "Dad didn't know."

Moriah: "My son has not mentioned Carmel since the incident, although I told him the kindergarten was closed. A month ago he surprised my husband, when during a trip he pointed to her house and said: 'Carmel lives here.' We were shocked. It shows the intensity of the trauma. He remembered Something he experienced at the age of two. "

Bat-El: "I noticed that every time I give a toy to my daughter, she goes to the corner and clings to the wall. Do you think it's something she brought with her from kindergarten?"

Yossi: "It makes sense. Sit her down gently in the center of the room, so you can see that everything is fine."

Reuben: "My son does not agree to sit in the car seat in the car, especially when I want to tie him up. He screams and rages. It is a long struggle with him."

Nicole: "The traumas don't go away in a second. Even though my son already looks fine, I discovered that in his subconscious, things still exist. If I open the door tightly while he sleeps, he clings to the side of the bed in a panic, without waking up. It's instinct, and it takes time to change him.

"My recommendation to you is to be attentive to the children, but also to change the way you behave at home. Be calm, without sharp movements."

Did you take the children for emotional therapy?

Moriah: "We debated with experts whether it was right to rekindle his memories. Now it's on the agenda."

Yossi: "I'm sure my daughter needs care too, but this year I let my fear take over the family. I didn't want the girl to deal with the memories."

Reuven: "We thought about it already last week, when they stopped the assistants, because I wanted to reflect to my son what happened. We turned to a psychologist who specializes in trauma, and she gave us four key sentences to tell the child: that the kindergarten is currently closed, that we know there was something wrong, "That it will not happen again, and that Mom and Dad are taking care of it now. I admit that to this day we have not found the strength to tell him these sentences."

Maor: "I'm going to say exactly those words to my son."

"Give a corrective experience"

The conversation slides deep into the night. Moriah, Yossi and Nicole sit together on the swing in the yard, the rest sit on the grass. The parents from Ramla want to get to know every teacher who stood in the way of the parents from Rosh HaAyin.

Bat-El: "I want to understand, no one here has considered the option of simply staying home with the children? I am undecided, even though I have already closed a kindergarten for the girl for September."

Nicole: "I understand you, it was very difficult for me too, but in the end I decided it was important that they return to the frame and have a positive experience. In the first month, after I put them in the kindergarten, I sat every day in the principal's room and cried."

Bat-El: "I told my husband that maybe we should take advantage of the corona and sit at home. I will get social security, unemployment or whatever. He is against."

Yossi: "The girl was with us at home for four months. We stopped living. But then it was best to get her back in the frame." 

Bat-El: "In retrospect, do you feel it was true?"

Yossi: "When she was at home, it was right for us. I wanted her to be by my side so I could hug her all the time. When we brought her back to kindergarten, it was right for her."

Maor: "I also think that the children need a framework and need their friends. What do you say, should all the parents from the daycare center put the children in one kindergarten, or is it better to separate them?"

Yossi: "We did not do it. There is explosive potential here, it could bring the children back."

Hila: "We had an open safari meeting with all the children from the kindergarten at the time. When my son recognized them, he clung to me and refused to get out of hand. I think they reminded him of the period in Carmel kindergarten. If you want to continue together in one kindergarten, make sure the teacher is accompanied by a psychologist. ".

Nicole: "Maybe if you send them to kindergarten together, they will have good experiences, and that's what they will remember from each other."

Moriah: "A year ago I would have vehemently refused such an offer because I wanted to erase the trauma from memory. Today I believe it can be a remedial experience. To give abused children the opportunity to be together when they are released."

"Ask the kids"

In recent days, the parents have returned from a demonstration, and now the parents of the children from the nursery in Ramla have also joined them. They disagree on whether the demonstrations are achieving anything.

Yossi: "The fact that caregiver Tzipi David has now been sent to prison for a year, after years of abusive kindergarten teachers receiving only service jobs, is the conscious achievement of the parents' protest. Also the fact that the prosecution insists on ten years in prison for Carmel."

Nicole: "I have a hard time with the decision to postpone for a year the law that requires private kindergartens to install security cameras. We have an inflated government that is mainly busy in Corona and forgets that there are children here. We hope MK Ophir Katz from the Likud succeeds For abusive gardeners. He also got stuck because of the plague. "

What advice do you have for parents reading this article, to avoid what you have experienced?

Nicole: "They will open a WhatsApp group only for parents in kindergarten, without the kindergarten teachers, and there they will go up everything. They will report there if the child is in pain, if he is vomiting, or anything else. They will ask the other parents if they also have unusual symptoms. Pim to tell the teacher, but there is no need to shy away from it. The right of parents to talk to each other and also to take care of what is happening to their children. "

Moriah: "I recommend not calling a teacher or assistants."

Yossi: "I am in favor of insisting on online cameras, and not on closed-circuit cameras."

Halo: "Children should be asked clear questions about what they did in kindergarten. Parents can tell about the experiences they went through that day, thus getting the children to tell as well."

Nicole: "I am also in favor of surprise visits to the garden, although this is not possible during the Corona period."

Moriah: "You can put the child in a home that can be secretly peeked at from the outside."

Reuben: "Abdominal sensations must not be ignored in any way."

Jenny: "And don't be ashamed to demand to see the security camera videos. I don't 'like the kindergarten teacher', this is the life of your children."

Comments 

"Garden owners did not know about the violence"

Advocate Idit Reichert, representing Little and Moshe Bersi, said: "This is a tragic story, and the couple's life's work has collapsed. They ran a reputable nursing home. Below the surface, the aides used criminal violence against minors, under the watchful eye of the cameras, which were installed at the initiative of the kindergarten administrators. The couple deny that they knew about the violent incidents or were present at the time they happened. According to them, no complaint was ever raised by the parents. They cooperated with the police and consensually handed over the cameras. The investigation is still under development, and it is too early to discuss the gap between the police's claims and the couple's version. "

Attorney Yaron Forer, representing Nirit Schweid, said: "The aides have been detained since July 27, and despite the long time, the investigators have not yet presented them with the full evidence. As for Nirit, she has not been shown a single film in which she is allegedly performing an act of violence. Keep in mind that detention is not a down payment at the expense of punishment, so I intend to petition for her immediate release. Regarding the previous offense, this is an idle complaint that was made in the course of legal proceedings. "

Attorney Shlomi Bizek, representing Orly Shragani, said: "I understand the parents' pain and regret it, but it should be remembered that the defense attorneys have not yet been exposed to the investigation material. Orly's relative share in the affair is minor, and a clear distinction must be made between her and the other suspects. In her case the case can be closed with nothing. Since her arrest on July 29, she has only been questioned once. "We will grant her immediate release, as she is currently being held hostage by the police in order to establish suspicions against the other detainees."

Advocate Moshe Algali, representing Ruhama Saad, said: "At this stage we have not yet watched the videos, so we do not know what the police have against any suspect. My client claims her complete innocence, and I currently have no way of refuting the parents' claims. "

Advocate Avichai Hajabi, representing Hani Nana Tzatshvili, stated: "The descriptions that appear in the article are not attributed to my client. The attempt to paint it in the same colors as the aides who worked in the nursery were painted is wrong. We hope that by filtering out the background noise and publicity in the case, the court will order her release. "

Advocate Ofer Rasho, representing Inbar Donio, stated: "My client was questioned regarding what is attributed to her, which is completely different from what is described in the article. She worked in another part of the garden and was not on the relevant floor. The judge hearing her case ruled that the suspicion against her was low-level violence, and there is controversy over that as well. My client claims that she did not use violence against the child. "

tala@israelhayom.co.il

 For donations to support the struggle >>

https://beactive.co.il/project/59505