Because her ex-boyfriend is said to have filmed the love game together, a woman (21) has taken revenge in Karlsfeld.
It scratched the man's Mercedes AMG.
A 20-year-old from Karlsfeld scratched her ex-boyfriend's Mercedes AMG.
For this the young woman came to court.
The man's appearance sparked sympathy with the judge - for the defendant.
Dachau
-
It was probably not
a
great love
that connected a then 20-year-old from Karlsfeld and a 21-year-old from Dachau last winter.
"It wasn't bad, it was okay, we just had something together," the young man described the relationship between the two yesterday in front of magistrate Christian Calame.
So it happened that the couple met on the evening of February 20 in a
hotel in Dachau-Ost
- "for consensual sexual intercourse," as the indictment said.
Filmed while making love: Woman (21) scratched Mercedes AMG of her ex-boyfriend
What happened after this act, however, the statements differed widely.
She claimed he
filmed
her having
sex,
which led to an
argument
and she left the hotel.
A buddy picked them up and they drove aimlessly through the night.
He said, however, that he had absolutely not filmed her, instead she was "
fucked up"
because he wanted to go home immediately after the lovemaking.
Then she and her buddy
drove
to the
Allguth gas station
in
Karlsfeld
and
scratched
his
Mercedes AMG
, which was parked there in the unlit backyard
.
Damage:
6901.87 euros.
"Treated like a whore": Woman admits scratching the Mercedes in a cell phone message
The problem: The supposedly shot
video doesn't exist
(anymore).
But there is video from a
surveillance camera
that filmed the young woman's friend's car driving into and out of the gas station.
There is also a
cell phone conversation between
the two of them, in which he wrote: "Dude, why did you scratch my car?" And she replied: "Because you
treated
me
like a whore
!"
In court, however, the 21-year-old denied any guilt.
She was absolutely not angry about the video, "rather in the sad mode".
In addition, she
has been filmed several
times: "I would have to scratch a car every time!" She only
drove through the area
after the
hotel rendezvous
with an old friend, a 24-year-old from Dachau, until she then -
after three vodka-lemon cans
- confessed that she had "scratched" her arms again.
Ex-boyfriend's car scratched: evidence against woman from Karlsfeld overwhelming
The friend, also on the witness stand, confirmed this version and also stated that he wanted to see the injury at the next best possible place.
And that was - what a coincidence - of
all things
, the
Allguth petrol station in Karlsfeld,
in whose backyard the
AMG was
parked.
The prosecutor wanted to know why he hadn't parked on the illuminated street or at the petrol pumps, but instead - with the lights switched off - drove behind into the dark courtyard.
The answer to that was poor: "I just didn't want to park on the street."
Dachau: Oppressive burden of proof against 21-year-olds - but mild judgment
Sure, the appearance of the 21-year-old
Mercedes-AMG owner
almost
felt sympathy for the accused
from the judge and prosecutor
.
How he
sat on the stand in
his
Louis Vuitton sneakers
and declared that
"she's not the only one I go to the hotel with".
Or as the public prosecutor asked him: “Do you actually often argue with women?” And he replied with a counter question: “Do you have a wife?
You argue with women, man. "
In any case, Judge Calame called it
“a huge mess, it just doesn't work”
to film his partner during sexual intercourse against her will.
Precisely because of this, however, it is all the more plausible that the young woman
scratched her ex-partner's car
in a “simple, perhaps
justified act of revenge”
.
In the end, the judge found the evidence for this to be overwhelming: "You had a motive, you were disinhibited due to alcohol and you knew where his car was." Because of the "extremely high damage" he should actually
impose
a
youth
arrest sentence.
However, he considered it "educationally necessary, but also sufficient"
to condemn
the young woman from Karlsfeld to
serve 48
hours of community service.