news
News in Israel
Criminal news and law
Police have announced that the murder in Haifa has been solved, but the lawyers think otherwise
Defense attorneys argue that pointing the finger of blame at Nadaa Broad's brother, who was himself murdered shortly after her disappearance, is an attempt to get out of a duty that comes at a strange time.
Last month, her parents and even a friend of the son were arrested on suspicion of involvement in the murder - and released.
"The claim that the murder was solved is outrageous"
Tags
Haifa
murder
Yoav Itiel
Sunday, 17 January 2021, 21:32
Share on Facebook
Share on WhatsApp
Share on general
Share on general
Share on Twitter
Share on Email
0 comments
She was never declared missing.
Nadaa Broad (Photo: Unnamed)
The police announcement of the decipherment of the murder of Nadaa Brod in Haifa today (Sunday) provoked resentment in the legal community.
Many lawyers in the city claim that pointing the finger of blame at the 19-year-old brother, who was murdered shortly after her disappearance in 2005, is an attempt to get out of duty, which comes at a strange time - the month her parents were arrested and released.
On the other hand, some have accepted the solution of the complicated case as a significant achievement.
"The claim that the murder was solved is outrageous," he told Walla!
NEWS A veteran Haifa lawyer who has been involved in the case for many years.
"This is an unprecedented low in the Israel Police. They are treating the murder of her brother, who cannot defend himself against this claim because he was murdered himself."
In contrast, another Haifa lawyer familiar with the case claims that it was a huge success for the police, who were able to link the circumstantial evidence to the forensic evidence, and with the help of advanced technology that did not exist when she was murdered, deciphered the mystery 16 years after it began.
More on Walla!
NEWS
After 16 years: The police solved the murder of a young woman in Haifa by her brother
To the full article
More on Walla!
NEWS
The sentence was aggravated: 20 months in prison for Ronen Beatty who sexually assaulted fans of his daughter the singer
Stabbed, escaped, and hid the knife: A 16-year-old boy is accused of murdering a young man in Tirat Carmel
Returning to Istanbul: A travel diary with a group of hair transplant recipients
"Murder of her brother, who can not defend himself."
Haifa Police Station (Photo: Yoav Itiel)
Nadaa's body was discovered in the Ofer Forest last April by KKL-JNF employees, wrapped in a blanket. The police investigation was assigned to the unit for fighting crime in the Asher area. A sweeping publication ban was imposed on the affair even then, .
the parents of Nidaa, originally from Gaza, were arrested last month on suspicion of the murder of their daughter, conspiracy to commit a crime and its prevention. in addition, parents were also arrested Tayseer Brod, a former inmate age of 64, serving more than 20 years in prison and his wife Faiza Brod, 57. Amir Mahamid, a 36-year-old resident of Haifa, a good friend of the son suspected of the murder, was also arrested. After a month, the mother was released under house arrest by her daughter, who lives in Fureidis, and the father and friend were later released.
Many tragedies shook the 11-year-old family
Many tragedies befell the Broad family.
Nadaa's father has previously been convicted in dozens of cases of drug offenses, extortion, violence, weapons and security offenses.
"This is not a one-time stumble but a dismal way of life and even his source of livelihood," the police claimed against him in 2013, when they again asked to detain him until the end of the proceedings in the case in which Judge Dr. Zayed Fallah convicted him of operating a drug station in Hadar HaCarmel. Four years in prison.
This is a family of 11 children, learning of the tragedies that upset the family. They came to Israel without the extended family, after the father helped the security forces in Gaza for many years. Their 4-year-old daughter was murdered in 1999 at the residence, their 24-year-old son was murdered He and another girl also tried to commit suicide at the age of 16 by jumping from the second floor window of the house. She was seriously injured and hospitalized. During one of the mother's visits to her daughter, she was also run over, injured and hospitalized
. She has asked authorities several times to locate the lost daughter, but officially Nada Brod has never been declared missing. "She was told she was an adult and had the right to sever ties," family insiders claim.
"Investigative exercises that should not be done."
Complaints against the conduct of the police (Photo: Aviv Hofi)
Muhammad Brod, who according to the police murdered his sister Nadaa, was murdered himself on one of the days in March 2005. In the evening, a birthday party was held in Haifa for the person accused of the murder, Raja Bashtawi.
During the party, an argument developed whose cause is unknown between Brod and Bashtawi, during which they both left the apartment and continued with an argument that escalated into shouting and quarreling, during which Brod stabbed Bashtawi in the stomach.
At the shouts, those present at the party were called out and separated, but in a hurry he freed himself from the grip of those around him, ran to his house, took a knife from the kitchen and returned to where Brod was standing.
He stabbed Brod three times - two in the chest and one in the left arm, and immediately fled.
The Haifa District Court sent Bestawi to 16 years in prison, after he was convicted of manslaughter as part of a plea deal.
Advocate Hamudi Masri, who represented Amir Mahamid, reacted skeptically to the decipherment of the murder. "I sincerely hope that instead of the police bragging and announcing in one speculation or another the decipherment of murder cases without filing an indictment, Hundreds of unsolved murder cases. "
"This is a murder that agitated Haifa, and came to an end with the release of the parents"
Adv. Shadi Saruji and Adv. Tami Ullman
"It is difficult for me with such investigations in which parents hold detention and point the finger of blame at them even after they already know who the killer is, they extend their detention again and again. There is no justification for this," said attorney Tami Ullman, who represented Tyser Brod along with attorney Shadi Serug. From her office. "The courts in judicial decisions have completely cleared the deceased's parents of involvement in her murder. If they knew the killer was the son who was murdered, then why were the parents detained for so long, when all along they claimed they did not know who the killer was and claimed innocence?"
Advocate Ullman added that “we appeared in court for a whole month and tried to convince him that they had been caused a great injustice by being detained. The police did investigative exercises that should not be done in a family setting, and all this in an attempt to indict the parents for no wrong in their palm, even though along the way they claimed their innocence. "
She added that" the parents were completely shocked by the murder of their home. Talk about her disappearance. The family is hurting the severe grief in which they find themselves and even expresses their displeasure about the publication of the lies that are throwing mud on the family.
"" This is a murder case that upset Haifa, and came to an end with the release of the deceased murdered parents, " , Tami Ullman and Shadi Seroji who represented the parents. "This is a planned murder in which it was decided to kill the victim in the background of the deceased leaving the parents' house. The court ordered the release of the parents who were proven to have no awareness of the death." Defense attorneys added that they "express surprise at the timing of the publication, and make it clear that their clients have no part in the murder."
The police said that "the Israel Police conducted a professional, thorough investigation, with the aim of investigating the truth, in which it arrested and questioned a number of suspects involved in the incident. All investigations were accompanied by the prosecution and a professional court examination, according to hearings."
Share on Facebook
Share on WhatsApp
Share on general
Share on general
Share on Twitter
Share on Email
0 comments
