Members of the Legislative Council severely criticized yesterday (4th) that the Director of the Medical and Health Bureau, Lo Chongmao, declared that seven doctors suspected of spamming "needle-free paper" issued more than 30,000 pieces of needle-free paper are all invalid. There is no legal basis and "imperious".
The incident has attracted heated discussions in the political and social circles. Jiang Yuhuan spoke again today (5th) evening, hoping to return to rational discussions, reiterating that there is nothing wrong with asking the government to treat the incident with reason, emotion and law.
Legislative Councilor Li Haoran disagreed with Jiang Yuhuan's criticism, arguing that Lu Chongmao's approach was to prevent misconduct and prevent the continuation of criminal behavior.
The "needle-free paper" incident of the vaccine pass, Jiang Yuhuan criticized the one-off cancellation of the needle paper involved in the case as unreasonable, causing discussion in the political circles.
(file picture)
Jiang Yuhuan: It is not inappropriate to ask the government to treat it with reason and law
Jiang Yuhuan posted on Facebook again about the "needle-free paper" incident.
She said that every case and opinion for assistance has been carefully read. As a lawyer and a member of the Legislative Council, it is your duty to look at a law with a neutral, impartial and rational attitude, and to ask officials to explain it with reason.
She stressed that the "Chapter 599" ordinances have a great impact on people's daily life, and it is not inappropriate to ask the government to treat it with reason, emotion and law.
Jiang Yuhuan said that there were many irrational messages after posting yesterday, but smears of politicization were not taken into account.
She said that only by returning to rational discussion will Hong Kong go further and further forward. As long as there is a public feedback one day, she will take the facts and laws of the case seriously.
Li Haoran believes that it is not difficult for eligible citizens to find another doctor to prescribe "needle-free paper".
(File photo / Photo by Lu Yiming)
Li Haoran: Citizens who meet the exemption qualifications can find another doctor to reissue the certificate
The incident has also been discussed a lot in the political circles.
Li Haoran disagreed with Jiang Yuhuan's criticism, pointing out that "reasonable suspicion" was just a vague expression, and in this case, seven doctors issued more than 30,000 "needle-free papers", which were obviously problematic. How about stopping these exemptions on the premise?"
As for whether they will "kill a good citizen by mistake", Li Haoran believes that it is not difficult for some qualified citizens to find another doctor to issue another certificate.
If it fails to do so, "Should there be reasonable suspicion that these certificate holders are in fact conspiring with those doctors to abuse immunity?"
Li Haoran believes that it is more efficient to cancel all the certificates involved in consideration of the public interest before the final result is obtained. The cancellation of these certificates "is precisely to stop the continuation of criminal behavior", and Lu Chongmao's approach is to prevent Such misconduct is considered legal and reasonable.
The 20,000 needle-free paper will expire next week. Jiang Yu denounced the tyranny and no legal basis: Who broke the rule of law?
Dismantling the situation ︱ Jiang Yuhuan criticizes the Secretary for being "arbitrary" in the political circles, astonishing scholars: dare to say that the space for councillors is still limited
