It took ten years to produce and directed by Maggie Cheung's Yinghua Girls' School Reconstruction Documentary "For My Nineteen-Year-Old Me", which sparked controversy over the ethics of the documentary. Today marks the fourth day (5th) of its official launch, and it is also the last broadcast before the show is suspended. day.
Some viewers who had just learned about the incident felt that the current reports were one-sided and it was difficult to judge who was right and who was wrong, and praised the film for making parents reflect.
Some college student viewers expressed that they understand that they don't want their past life to be exposed to the public, so they agree with the decision of the film studio to suspend the broadcast, "If I knew it, I probably wouldn't watch it."
▼February 5, the day before the suspension of the release of "For Me at the Age of Nineteen"▼
+2
The audience led Zhang Wanting to thank her for her votes: Every film has its own destiny
"To the Nineteen-Year-Old Me" has become more and more turbulent, although it has been announced that it will stop broadcasting tomorrow.
The 6:40 p.m. screening at the Koh Sin Theater in Kennedy Town will continue to be shown as usual.
According to the audience, there was no booing at the scene when thanking the votes. Director Maggie Cheung said at the time: "Every film has its own destiny."
▼Screenshot of "For Me at Nineteen"▼
+4
The audience said that it was unclear whether the two sides were right or wrong, and the praise brought out reflection on the value of life
After thanking the votes, about dozens of spectators left the theater. Among them, Mrs. Lam admitted that she did not know the details of the incident, but believed that the report's description was one-sided, and it was difficult for the public to understand the consent forms signed by the students involved in the past.
"It's OK to watch it as a set of movies."
She also pointed out that it is temporarily unclear whether the two parties are right or wrong. If you ignore the storm and watch the work, it will indeed bring out the value of reflecting on life.
But she understands the reluctance of the students involved, "I understand that some students find it embarrassing to watch, but there are a lot of points for parents to reflect on."
Her husband, Mr. Lin, added that some students had emotional problems and were worried that the continued screening would affect their studies and life.
Classmate Liu pointed out that the movie tickets had been purchased long before the turmoil. "If I had known, I probably wouldn't have watched it." (Photo by Ouyang Dehao)
CUHK students agree to stop the broadcast: better compensation
Liu, a student from CUHK from the Mainland, said that the movie tickets had been bought long before the turmoil. "If I had known, I probably wouldn't have watched it." Sign the consent form, but the filming progress has reached halfway, and the film party has paid a lot of costs, it is not the director or anyone who can make the decision.
But she understands that the students involved are not public figures, and she is worried that the past life will be watched by all Hong Kong people, so she agrees with the decision of the film studio to suspend the broadcast.
"I think the director's decision to suspend the public screening today is also a better compensation."
Maggie Cheung launched a new documentary "For Me at the age of 19". After being negatively commented by the first audience on the Internet earlier, after Director Zhang joined the "Task Force for Promoting Hong Kong's New Advantages", netizens called for a boycott.
("To Me at Nineteen" movie poster)
To the nineteen-year-old me｜The former principal of Yinghua Girls’ School apologized to the alumni: As the promoter, I have the duty to give to the nineteen-year-old me｜The petition stated that the document signed by the underage is invalid and the public screening needs to be signed to the nineteen-year-old me｜ Zhang Wanting speaks out: The girl involved agreed to participate in the film festival and private screenings for me at the age of 19︱Li Huishi did not agree to the interview film compilation: I will not watch it and do not encourage you to watch it