The Limited Times

Now you can see non-English news...

A black swan on the rubble of the earthquake in Turkey

2023-02-11T09:52:06.874Z


The tragedy disrupts the political path of the Erdogan government, in a mirror to what happened 20 years ago, with another earthquake, with thousands of deaths, which broke the country's power structure.


Nothing new.

In Turkey, earthquakes have

buried and given birth to governments

.

It happened 20 years ago.

But it is not only the tragedy that persists in repeating itself even in detail, but the premeditated inefficiency of governments to deal with these challenges and especially to prevent them. 

The current disaster, with a mountain of thousands of deaths, is

a Black Swan

that suddenly appears among the rubble to revive this possible political scenario and unexpectedly define the fate of the controversial autocracy led by Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

Turkey is a key regional power in global geopolitics, but it suffers from

some of the highest inflation in the world

, close to 62 percent a year.

Argentines who suffer levels well above that number know well what this calamity is about and the anti-system effect it produces.

The enormous earthquake that has shaken the south of that country and the north of Syria, with at least 16,000 dead according to very provisional figures, is a shot below the waterline of an economy with these serious problems.

It happens on the threshold of

national elections

 scheduled for May 14 that were already very complicated for Erdogan.

This panorama parallel to the moving information about the tragedy, in an area with little supplies, with a reduced presence of the State and an opaque administration that can explain the absence of anti-seismic systems that would have mitigated the disaster, is now

an unexpected player at the polls

.

The crisis is exacerbated by the denunciation of an

ineffective assistance structure for the victims

.

The multitude of criticisms infuriated the regime, which resorted to typical techniques of a country involved in censorship for years, with Internet filters to prevent the dissemination of inconvenient reports and with the president himself warning against the "lies" that are spread against of his government.

There is also a recent law operating, similar to those promoted by Vladimir Putin, the good friend of the Turkish president, which

punishes with between one and three years in prison

those who disseminate information that the authorities consider false, that is, information critical of the Turkish authorities.

Only praise is accepted.

But this cataclysm goes beyond any Orwellian strategy.

It affects millions of people over hundreds of kilometers in excess of the enormous number of fatalities.

"The scale of the disaster will completely reset the Turkish economy and politics," Atilla Yesilada, of the Global Source Partners financial firm

, told

Reuters .

One measure of the blow was exposed by the BIT100, the benchmark Turkish stock index, which plunged 8.6% after the disaster and continued to fall in subsequent trading.

The Turkish lira also reached a new low, accentuating the collapse it is experiencing due to the curious policy of the government of

lowering interest rates despite high inflation.

The disaster fuels

doubts that it will be possible to vote

in the affected regions, a fact that could favor Erdogan because those wastelands are largely Kurdish, among other oppositions.

Aerial view on February 8, 2023 of rescuers searching for survivors among the rubble of a destroyed building.

Xinhua Photo

Maneuver and state of emergency


The powerful Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP), a Kurdish nationalist force, has long been the target of

possible banning

because it stands in the way of the restoration of the monarchy sought by the president.

Now confronted with this nightmare, the regime has gone a long way and has just declared a

state of emergency

for three months, a period in which it will be possible to govern by decree, bypassing Parliament and, of course, the regional authorities in the hands of the opposition.

Nothing is random.

It is interesting to note that the special powers that the ruler granted himself after the glassy 2016 coup attempt expire in May, 

just before the presidential elections.

The earthquake has, however, an unavoidable electoral power that overwhelms any maneuver and this was noted on the ground.

Kieren Barnes, Syria director for

aid group Mercy Corps

, said the initial period after the quake had been characterized by

"chaos, confusion and fear

. "

Not only in the Arab country.

The

Financial Times

quoted people complaining about the absence of rescue teams, or a significant delay, as they battled a lack of drinking water and electricity

amid freezing temperatures

and with survivors ensconced in the rubble of their homes.

Meanwhile, the experts revealed that the low quality of the buildings and

the lack of resistance to earthquakes

of these constructions contributed to the high levels of destruction.

Kishor Jaiswal, a scientist with the US Geological Survey, estimated that many buildings in the region "were not designed with seismic considerations in mind with the capacity to absorb so much ground motion."

The paradoxes surrounding this disaster are multiple.

Erdogan is a son-in-law of such a calamity,

a mirror in which he hates to look at himself

.

In 1999, an earthquake devastated northwestern Turkey, killing

17,000 people

.

Nothing different from the current nightmare.

File image of Bülent Ecevit, the first Turkish leader who fell after the huge earthquake of 1999 and gave way to the Erdogan administration.

AFP photo

The prime minister at the time, Bülent Ecevit, took three days to visit the destroyed cities and

the distribution of humanitarian aid was slow and disorganized.

The natural disaster highlighted steep government corruption coincident with building code violations that mandated earthquake-resistant structures on paper.

More similarities.

That disaster joined the economic crisis of the years 2000 and 2001 and strengthened the population's weariness against the

sewers of power

.

As the journalist Lucas Proto recalls from Ankara in

El Confidencial, 

this disruptive scenario projected the rise of the Justice and Development Party (AKP), founded by Erdogan.

He won in 2002 and

has not relinquished power since

, first as prime minister then as president when the country's parliamentary system came to an end.

There are five terms, not counting his time as mayor of Istanbul when he presented himself as a secular, hard-line leader.

Religion has been a tool to stem the loss of voters to the Turkish half that is perceived as European on the other side of the Bosphorus.

He easily discovered that

the Islamization of the story would tie the vote of the humblest sectors

of the population, who are usually the most conservative.

Then he came to prohibit kissing in public and emphasize the place in the kitchen of women among other

medieval creations.

The main rival


Today the president's main rival is Ekrem Imamoglu, a constitutionalist social democrat and defender of secularism, the current mayor of Istanbul.

This leader with a determined tone, already defeated the ruling party in the 2019 municipal elections, an election where the creeper of power that manages the autocracy

forced a repeat of the elections to try to get him out of the way.

Challenging.

The opposition leader Ekrem Imamoglu, mayor of Istanbul, social democrat and defender of secularism.

AP Photo

But the result of the second attempt was even more favorable to the opposition leader.

A foretaste of the electorate's mood.

That is why the regime invented a series of cases against the leader to

get him out of the race

, including trying to send him to jail because he questioned the members of the electoral board who made the surprising decision against his initial victory . .

It is not clear what will happen in May, except that if Erdogan retains power he will surely become radicalized.

But he would follow the path of Ecevit in different dimensions.

There are unavoidable costs.

Any mutation in that sphere is of key importance because Turkey is a crucial member of NATO and a bridge today with the Kremlin to find a solution to the

Russian alley of the war in Ukraine

.

But, essentially, also because the regime is committed to a restoration of Ottomanism,

in principle devouring territories in the Moscow backyard.

It is already happening with the savage war of its Azerbaijani satellite in the South Caucasus against the Armenian enclave of Nagorno Karabagh with its population subjected to a siege of food and water that has been going on for two months these days.

Or, furthermore, disseminating maps with

the Turkish flag on the Greek islands of the Aegean Sea.

The Black Swan of the earthquake now hovers over these abuses.

It will be seen how far it rises. 


© Copyright Clarin 2023


look too

The earthquake in Turkey as a preview of the electoral fight

Earthquake in Turkey and Syria: desolation in Iskenderun, a city devastated by the earthquake

Source: clarin

All news articles on 2023-02-11

You may like

Trends 24h

Latest

© Communities 2019 - Privacy

The information on this site is from external sources that are not under our control.
The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation or endorse the views expressed within them.