As of: February 10, 2024, 7:08 a.m
By: Karsten Hinzmann
Comments
Press
Split
Expensive purchase for Defense Minister Boris Pistorius: The entire force will receive new hearing protection with radio options.
The Federal Audit Office criticizes both the price and the sense of the purchase.
© IMAGO/David Inderlied/Kirchner Media
Hearing protection with a microphone for the entire force - in times of tight budgets, the Bundeswehr buys expensive equipment.
According to the Federal Audit Office, this is cheaper.
Berlin – Boris Pistorius and Kay Scheller calculate differently.
Federal Defense Minister Boris Pistorius (SPD) expects what could come: an operation.
The President of the Federal Audit Office expects what is happening: low tide in the cash register.
After criticism from the Federal Audit Office in mid-December about the purchase of machine guns, the Bundeswehr is now being brushed off again - with the same reason: the Bundeswehr is buying equipment that it will never use.
The Federal Audit Office is currently criticizing the procurement of around 200,000 “talking sets with hearing protection function” (SMG), as they are called in official German.
As
Spiegel
first reported, the Federal Audit Office criticized the fact that all soldiers should receive these headphones with radio communication, although in their opinion only a fifth of those equipped would use the radio function.
The rest lacked a radio, meaning the headphones would be largely useless and would therefore be oversized and therefore too expensive.
The long-term order with a volume of around three billion euros therefore offers savings potential of more than a third.
The new Bundeswehr deal: hearing protection with radio for the infantrymen
In January 2023, Boris Pistorius took office as Defense Minister with the aim of equipping the Bundeswehr faster, cheaper and more practicably.
“We will no longer be able to stop ongoing projects unless they fail,” the SPD politician told the
Tagesschau
at the time.
Other projects should therefore continue, “because we are working within the framework of contracts,” as he said.
But “from now on” there will be an end to “golden edge solutions” for the procurement of projects and especially their planning, emphasized the Defense Minister.
Pistorius inherited hearing protection from his predecessor Christine Lambrecht (SPD).
This is part of a package of measures that she completed in mid-2022 to fully equip the troops with personal protective equipment by 2025;
Part of this is also a combat helmet, onto which attachments should be attached in a modular manner.
In this context, the approximately 200,000 speaking sets with hearing protection functions were also put out to tender - as the
Federal Office for Equipment, Information Technology and Use of the Bundeswehr
writes: "The aim and purpose of this procurement is hearing protection that is compatible with the soldier's equipment (head protection area: combat helmet, shooting goggles) , which offers the soldier maximum protection, minimizes the risk of permanent hearing damage, ensures communication under the conditions when firing small arms/anti-tank hand weapons and allows the perception of environmental noise.
The speaking set with hearing protection function should be primarily suitable for dismounted forces or infantry use outside of vehicles.”
The Federal Audit Office
After the end of each financial year, the federal government must report to the Bundestag and the Bundesrat.
The Bundestag and Bundesrat then decide whether to grant the federal government discharge for the relevant financial year.
“Our comments are an important basis for the discharge procedure.
They analyze the federal government's income and expenditure, its assets and its debts.
And they make recommendations on how deficits can be eliminated and budget resources can be used more efficiently and effectively.”
– Source: Federal Audit Office
In October 2022, the Bundestag released funds for a first tranche of 3,665 of these hi-fi headphones: around 7.5 million euros.
With modern digital capsule hearing protection, soldiers should be able to regulate the volume of ambient noise or conversations.
Impulse sound – such as that from shots or detonations – is automatically filtered.
Radio devices can be connected to the speaking set using an adapter, so that radio communication is possible even with hearing protection.
The cook can do without it, and so can soldiers on supply or staff duty.
My news
Emergency for Putin's troops: Swedish tank mixes up the front
Nickname “Butcher”: Medvedev rails against new Ukraine army chief – read “Contempt and Disgust”.
Missile from Russia flies towards Poland – Warsaw puts air force on alertread
“War must be brought to Russia”: CDU expert calls for escalation – against the worst case scenario
Lindner is surprised in the interview: “I have never spoken to Mr. Kühnert personally” read
Baerbock's grandfather allegedly "unconditional National Socialist" - file was "not known" to the minister read
Pistorius' new hi-fi headset for the Bundeswehr: unit price 14,000 euros
Experts are amazed at how author “DL2MCD” writes in
Funkamateur
magazine : Headphones with ANC – Active Noise Cancellation, i.e. active suppression of ambient noise – cost a maximum of 400 to 600 euros for private use, even for top models.
The technology behind it was originally developed for pilots and is now also installed in smartphones.
203,000 hearing protection headphones with a speaking function will cost the Bundeswehr almost 2.8 billion euros, as
Spiegel
reports.
That's almost 14,000 euros per headphone!
According to
Spiegel,
up to 2,600 euros of this are for pure hardware costs, including maintenance, which is set for seven years.
The intended protection is possible with simpler models, warns the Federal Audit Office - which the Defense Department even confirmed in a statement, as Spiegel
writes
.
However, the ministry failed to provide a justification for the need for every soldier to have a speaking function.
Instead, according to the ministry, the procurement is “future-oriented and ensures uniform training, even if not all soldiers can use the speech sentence function in the near future.”
As a result, there is a “massive gain in ability” that would not be possible with hearing protection alone.
Bundeswehr procurement: But no end to the “golden edge solutions”
Shortly after the tender for the debatable hearing protection, an expert hearing took place in the Parliament's Economic Committee on the Bundeswehr Procurement Acceleration Act (BwBBG) at the beginning of July 2022, which was subsequently passed.
In the panel of experts, Annette Lehnigk-Emden made a very clear statement: “The demands are too high.
Our documents sometimes describe gold-edged solutions,” complained the President of the Federal Office for Equipment, Information Technology and Use of the Bundeswehr.
Then it is “the task up to the inspector general, together with the receivables controlling, to reduce the receivables and determine whether 80 percent of the receivables fulfillment is enough, with which one could then buy a product that is available on the market.”
The Federal Audit Office is not very impressed by the diffuse “capability gain” of the desired solution.
“The Federal Ministry of Defense’s reference to the fact that every soldier can at least use the hearing protection function does not convince the Federal Audit Office,” he writes in his assessment;
This would also work with standard market products.
Consequently, the Budget Committee should significantly reduce the planned framework agreement.
Documents from the Ministry of Defense are also said to have been missing.
For example, answers were refused to the question of whether modern headphones might be fully usable in the future because the Bundeswehr wants to purchase radio equipment for all soldiers.
Pistorius' promise: "I want to heal what needs to be healed"
The list of bizarre decisions runs through the history of the Bundeswehr, and the Court of Auditors repeatedly raises its finger - around ten years ago the
Spiegel
reported : Last November, the Federal Court of Auditors criticized the spending of around 20 million euros on the construction of a new factory had flowed into which the Bundeswehr had its own line of medicines and cosmetics manufactured.
According to the auditors, the products manufactured there, such as nasal spray, sun cream or lip protection sticks, could be purchased much more cheaply - on the open market.
The President of the Bundeswehr Procurement Office reassures: “You can’t compare us with the purchasing department of a car manufacturer,” says Annette Lehnigk-Emden.
In it she may have actually identified the problem: “Are the wrong people negotiating?” asked
Deutschlandfunk
.
“The ministry is often represented by experts, accompanied by lawyers.
The lawyers in the Ministry of Defense do not have the best reputation internally.
On the industrial side, Bundeswehr insiders report, lawyers and business people are increasingly negotiating, but no longer technicians as before. The aim is to receive orders, everything else is sorted out in the course of production.
The passage from
Deutschlandfunk
is ten years old.
The most recent Bundeswehr procurement disaster was less than six months ago: hastily purchased digital radios did not fit into the vehicles to be equipped.
Federal Defense Minister Pistorius went on the defensive, as quoted by the
Neue Zürcher Zeitung
.
“I would have assumed that before the order was placed, but at least when the order was placed, people would think about how the integration would take place.” He clarified why that didn’t happen and is now trying to “heal what needs to be healed.”
(Karsten Hinzmann)