Attached are the documents of the members of the Biebs family being taken away on October 7 by their captors in Gaza, Mizrah Khan Yunis/IDF Spokesman
"Turns the stomach" said Nir Dabori to Niv Raskin at about seven in the morning, about the video in which the children of the Biebs family and their mother are seen being led from near the border into the Gaza Strip.
After another cycle of a video that has no news value.
There is no disputing that even amid the general shock from the events of that Saturday, the story of the Biebs family managed to stand out: two small, peony children, a mother who begs for their lives and at the same time seeks to protect them in a lost situation.
There is no other expression so frustrating for the helplessness of the State of Israel and its glorious army that morning was lost.
It's just that the video published last night doesn't "turn your stomach" but only to the extent that it reminds you of the first video, the one of the kidnapping.
This is not only a result of what we see in it, but also of its quality: I was martyred on high I could stare at it again and again without understanding what was unfolding before my eyes.
Yes, after the commentary and explanations I was also able to identify more details, but as Jordan's sister, the father of the family - the aunt of the two sweet redheads - said (at the Marciano Foundation): she was relieved that at least there were no close-ups of their faces in this video, so that she can focus on what is happening around and not on the horror that must have been visible from their eyes.
As sad as it is to admit this, this video in itself has no value: it does not teach about the family's situation today - and as the IDF spokesman said himself, in the statement that the case should only be interpreted as an understatement: there is a very heavy fear for their fate.
In other words:
the IDF assumes that it knows What happened to them, but he still doesn't have conclusive evidence that will negate the remnant of hope that still remains - not only in the family but in the hearts of all the Israeli people who watch the pixelated video.
Shiri Biebs and her children are being held by a terrorist whose shirt is covered in blood.
The main contribution of the current video - by mentioning that video that was made before the horror that took place that day in the southern settlements/documentation on social networks according to Section 27 A of the Copyright Law
devoid of explanatory value
"It has an important explanatory value" - all the debaters in the studios agreed, but even this, forgive me, is nothing more than a quibble: the (technically) higher quality and more important film was already broadcast after October 7th.
Among the viewers in the world, those who watched it and were convinced that we are dealing with monsters and with a civil society that embraces them (meaning, innocent - less than it is acceptable to think in a world that fortunately has not yet encountered a culture that sanctifies death over life), have already been convinced.
Those who don't - these ten seconds won't convince him.
It is not that there is nothing to be done in view of the great Palestinian campaign that is sweeping the media channels in the West, especially in recent days (it seems that there is no one who is in frequent contact with colleagues abroad and did not feel a change of tone on their part, when the sincere concern was replaced by criticism - and not on personal or professional grounds), But in order to combat this, we must go back and mention the massacre that took place - there is more than enough photographic evidence of it, some of which did not make it into that famous "video of horrors"
. Until now, or worse - to believe that Israel directed it using artificial intelligence, probably won't be convinced anymore.
Those who still want to vent a little more frustration about the fact that Israel has no publicity, can always fire Noa Tashvi again or perhaps reduce the appearances of the English speaker The most eloquent of our explainers in the world, just because he once held a sign in Kaplan.
More in Walla!
Why did Ronan Tzur really retire from managing the abductees headquarters?
Depends on who you ask
To the full article
One-year birthday celebrations for Kafir Bibs in the Kidnapped Square.
Was he still alive at the time of the incident?
Just thinking about it makes my stomach turn
Believe it or not, another easy part, because this video also shows the helplessness of the State of Israel in regards to the fate of the abductees
In the news terms we're used to, it was a boring evening.
Maybe that's why this blurry video was broadcast again and again, the Prime Minister's response was brought up again, every angle of photography was analyzed again - in vain.
It is still a film of poor quality, the only benefit of which is the opportunity it provides to broadcast the documentation from the moment of the kidnapping itself, the moment that became the poster of the terrible hypocrisy at the most terrible moment for the people of Israel since the establishment of the state.
It can be assumed that several more of the type of this film will be discovered:
a large archive fell into the hands of the IDF. Is it also significant? Here the news interest is separate from the operational interest: if among the materials (presumably they have already been found) some are found that have immediate operational intelligence significance, then This will be kept a secret. What will reach the media will be what has only symbolic value: like Sinwar's experience in the tunnels, like (in contrast) moving three quarters of the Biebs family to a hiding place.
Turns the stomach? Maybe, but mostly designers: nerves first and foremost about the killers and the vile kidnappers, the perpetrators of the massacre (in the first video to which we were exposed, Shiri Biebs begs for her life and the lives of her children to a terrorist whose shirt is soaked in blood, apparently from one of the victims of the massacre). In contrast to them, of course, the anger also arises for anyone who falls asleep on guard, for any official who needs would have been prevented or at least saved - and failed in his mission.
And this, believe it or not, is another easy part, because this video also shows the powerlessness of the State of Israel in regards to the fate of the abductees: contrary to the cry of the unfortunate families, there is no practical proposal that is on the table that Israel can accept. It is a case that can be too easily blamed on Netanyahu, but one must honestly admit that no other Israeli leader, if he were in his shoes, would have been able to accept Hamas's demands.
Contrary to the claim of the officials, the opposite thesis also turned out to be wrong: no military pressure or military action will lead to a massive release of abductees.
The fact that two of them were rescued in the heroic operation only increases the frustration: even if we succeed - in a way that we cannot warn of - to carry out ten more such operations, more than a hundred hostages will remain in the hands of Hamas.
How many of them are among the living?
This is a scary question to even try and answer.
More in Walla!
Do you work at Karai?
The second authority refuses to reveal the amount of violations opened in the commercial channels
To the full article
The terrorists cover Biebs songs with a blanket.
Horrifyingly, in regards to the abductees, the IDF's helplessness is reminiscent of that of October 7/IDF Spokesman
The pleas are not just for kidnappers
Moreover, because the very unpleasant truth needs to be told: as time passes, the chance of a tactical release of some of the abductees in exchange for humanitarian aid decreases (among other things because it, alas, is given "for free" by the Israeli government, perhaps as a result of American pressure) and timed cease-fires .
We have already despaired of analyzing the mindset of the leader of Hamas, but it is likely that those in his hands will be held until the last moment, unless Israel agrees to give him a picture of victory.
she does not.
And here perhaps the film of the Biebs family takes on some symbolic meaning after all, being a painful reminder that brings together all our frustration and helplessness: the obstacles and the warning systems that failed on Command Day, the insufficient early preparation despite the warnings, the slow and clumsy response of the IDF to the attack (as a framework, no by local initiatives that wrote heroic plots) - and also of our frustrating inability today to bring about the release of the kidnapped or at least to provide reliable information about their fate.
The State of Israel and its army were caught unprepared on the day of the order: not only before her captors does the unfortunate Shiri Biebs plead, since human ills are Expectations.
She also begs for the help that the State of Israel failed to extend to her that Shabbat, help that to her horror she is unable to extend even today, after four and a half months of fighting and close to 500 fallen in the battle of the strongest army in the Middle East against the smallest of its enemies (in terms of the extent of the forces and the arsenal of weapons ), if you will, that's what really makes the belly.
More on the same topic:
Gaza war
abducted
IDF spokesperson
Nir Debori
Raskin dialect