After the Senate, the Assembly unanimously approved at first reading on Wednesday a bill aimed at recognizing and repairing the harm suffered by homosexual people due to discriminatory laws in force between 1942 and 1982.
The Assembly reestablished the principle of financial reparation for people convicted of homosexuality, and the creation of a commission responsible for ruling on requests for financial reparation, which the Senate had removed.
The text, initially carried by Senator Hussein Bourgi (PS), was the subject of a very broad consensus, 331 deputies having approved it out of 331, even if certain groups expressed reservations on the principle of reparation financial.
“We do not wish, like others, to distort (the law) by issues which would appear mercantile, which those interested elsewhere do not demand and which would tend to reduce our text to a simple creation of allowances”, notably explained RN deputy Sébastien Chenu.
“Totally unfair repression”
In his introductory remarks, Minister of Justice Éric Dupond-Moretti asked for forgiveness from people who are victims of discrimination because of their homosexuality.
“It is high time to (…) say this evening in the name of the French Republic: forgiveness, forgiveness to the people, to the homosexuals of France who have suffered for 40 years, this totally unfair repression.
Our Republic is never as beautiful as when it recognizes that it has lost track of its founding principles, freedom, equality, fraternity,” he underlined.
Also read: Michel, 75, was convicted of homosexuality: “I speak on behalf of those who are no longer here”
Dupond-Moretti, who in the Senate had gone in the direction of the rapporteur by considering the "implementation" of the compensation measure "extremely complex", this time said "hear (re) and share (r)" the “desire (…) that compensation be precisely set out in the law and implemented by a commission established ad hoc”.
But he drew attention to the fact that this commission would be faced with “probative difficulties”: “it will not be easy for certain people to prove that they have actually spent a specific time in prison or that they have paid the fine to which they had been sentenced.
It is therefore essential that in the final drafting of this text, we ensure not to create disappointments which would result from these evidentiary difficulties,” he warned.
The rapporteur of the text, the PS deputy Hervé Saulignac, considered that recognition could not go without reparation.
“I think France is capable of doing what Germany did, what the United Kingdom did, what Ireland did, what Spain did, what Canada did” , he argued, estimating that the number of people benefiting from reparation could be between 200, as in Spain, and 400, as in Germany.
The text will now resume its legislative journey in the Senate.