The 14th National Games will be held in Shaanxi on September 15.
In the last National Games, the Karate Federation was involved in unfair selection, and membership was suspended by the Hong Kong Association and Olympic Committee. The audit report was also criticized.
This selection is again controversial.
Zheng Ziwen, the last silver medalist in the men's "personal shape" and ranked about 30 in the world, was unsuccessful in the selection and scoring system. The representative of the Hong Kong team is the brother of Olympic bronze medalist Liu Mushang, who is currently ranked 127 in the world.
The selection mechanism is determined for each sports association based on the guidelines of the government and elite athletes from sports academies. However, "Hong Kong 01" found that the Karate Association did not calculate the results of the previous National Games, which is different from the government's criteria; The concept of scoring; the imbalance of scoring ratio; the late release of selection criteria and many other issues, Zheng Ziwen was therefore unsuccessful.
Mr. Airman stated that the entire selection process was fair and just, and in compliance with the government's "basic selection criteria."
01 Investigation series reports:
Karate Federation National Games selection again provokes controversy, last silver medal, world ranking 38 Zheng Ziwen lost
The Karate Federation was transferred to the current session by more than half of the DQ executive committee members of the Hong Kong Association DQ involved in the unfair selection of the last National Games
+7
I was greatly affected by this incident, so I had the idea of retiring or changing direction.
Zheng Ziwen (Silver Medalist at the 2017 National Games)
The National Games has joined the karate event since the last session. This year, Hong Kong and Macau have only one representative in each event. The Karate Federation will formulate a selection based on the "Basic Selection Guidelines" formulated by the National Games Preparatory Committee. The criteria and nominated athletes will be finally reviewed by the Hong Kong Government’s National Games Preparatory Committee.
But this year's selection mechanism has once again spread controversy.
This year’s National Games represented Hong Kong in the men’s "individual" event. It was Liu Mingming. His world and Olympic rankings were 127 and 105 respectively. However, Zheng Ziwen, the silver medalist in the men’s "individual" event, is accumulating points. Lost in the mechanism, his world and Olympic rankings are 38 and 29 respectively, far higher than Liu's well-known.
Zheng Ziwen was the silver medalist of the men's "personal shape" at the last National Games, but he was unsuccessful in the current selection mechanism.
(Picture from the official website of the Institute of Physical Education)
Empty total score table: National Games medals have 4 points
This year's Karate Federation uses a cumulative points system to calculate athletes' performance in different competitions at home and abroad in the last three years. The highest level of world competitions such as Olympics and World Championships can earn 6 points; Asian Games medals, Olympics or World Championships For the "4-8th place", 5 points will be awarded; 4 points will be awarded for Asian Championships or National Games medals; 2 points will be awarded for medals in National Championships.
▼Empty total score sheet, "Elite Training Funding Evaluation Criteria" and "Elite Funding Evaluation Criteria-General Scoring Table"▼
Only three years of results are different from government guidelines, the last silver medal is not scored
Although the team’s selection scoring list states that "National Games medals can get 4 points", as the team only calculates the results of the most recent three years, Zheng Ziwen’s last silver medal score is just the same for the four-year National Games. Will not be calculated.
However, according to the "Basic Selection Criteria" document of the National Games Preparatory Committee, the results of the previous National Games can also be considered for approving the qualifications of athletes. The general practice and guidelines are different.
SCO first refers to the "Elite Training Subsidy" guidelines of the Institute of Physical Education
Except for the silver medal in the last National Games that was not scored, the "9-16 Olympic and World Championships results" were also not considered.
Check the general selection guidelines. The scoring system is based on the "Elite Training Subsidy Calculation Criteria and the General Scoring Table of the Sports Academy". "World Championships 4-8" and "World Championships 9-16" results, athletes who meet the results contained in the results can receive different degrees of funding from the sports institute.
The scoring system is based on the "Elite Training Funding Calculation Criteria and the General Scoring Table of the Sports Institute". The "Elite Training Funding Evaluation Criteria" document of the Central Sports Institute contains the "World Championships Medals" and "World Championships". The results of the 4-8th place and the 9-16th place in the World Championships (marked in yellow).
Please refer to another table of the Sports Institute
In response, the general manager pointed out that they were referring to another part of the Sports Institute called "Elite Funding Evaluation Criteria-General Scoring Table". The biggest difference between the two documents was whether the "9-16 Olympics and World Championships were counted." score".
President Kong said that reporters did not count the scores when reviewing the documents containing "9-16 scores", so there was no "4 points criteria", and pointed out that the selection criteria of the preparation committee for the documents they referred to were also.
Zheng Ziwen, 32, reluctantly said that he still wants to hit the Asian Games, but because of the idea of retiring due to the loss of the National Games this time, the funding for the next year is likely to be reduced by two-thirds, from more than 30,000 yuan to 1 Ten thousand yuan in income.
(Photo by Lu Yiming)
Sports Institute: The reference document for the general manager is to evaluate different sports and not to evaluate individual athletes.
The Institute of Physical Education stated that the "Elite Funding Assessment Criteria-General Score Sheet" referenced by the Air Headquarters is used to assess whether a sport is an elite sport, not to assess individual athletes.
Liu Mingming finally won 20 points with 9 national championship medals, plus the 5th place in the World Super League, with a total of 23 points.
Due to the lack of calculation of "4 points for silver medal in the last National Games" and "9-16 place in the World Championships", Zheng Ziwen finally scored 19 points and lost by 4 points.
The reference documents are different, which directly affects the athletes' participation in the competition.
The selection mechanism is only ``released'' in May, athletes can't plan ahead
In addition to the selection and scoring criteria being questioned, the selection criteria that came out in May this year have also been criticized.
Zheng Ziwen said that the last National Games ended in 2017, but the selection and scoring system for this National Games was only released three to four months before the competition.
"If (announced) early in the morning (announcement), athletes and coaches can make the game plan early, not just now suddenly telling you that we have to count back the scores of the game a few years ago." He lamented that the game schedule in recent years has impacted the East Olympics, so he played He played a lot of world competitions and missed part of the national championships. In the end, he was unfortunately out of the Eastern Olympics qualifiers and failed to set foot on the Eastern Olympics stage.
Liu Mingming finally won 20 points with 9 national championship medals, plus the 5th place in the World Premier League, with a total of 23 points. By 4 points, he won the "individual" event of karate on behalf of Hong Kong.
(Information Picture / Photo by Liang Weiyang)
Won three mainland races with the same score as the Olympic medal
He confessed that the National Championship has 4 races and 1 final each year. If you get a medal, you will get 2 points and 3 points respectively. That is to say, you can get 11 points for all the above-mentioned competition medals every year, and you can get 33 points in three years. , Can get a lot of points.
Since only three years of results are counted, the four-year Olympic and World Championships can only win a maximum of 6 points. Zheng Ziwen frankly said that winning three domestic events is equivalent to winning the highest level of world events.
He pointed out that competition in the World Championships is also fierce, but the results of 9-16 in the highest level events are not included in the calculation, questioning whether the cumulative scoring mechanism can truthfully reflect the quality of athletes.
Two-thirds less funding may retire
"I think it is an unplanned selection mechanism. It is not a fair, open, just and transparent selection mechanism." Zheng Ziwen, 32, said helplessly. Losing the election leads to the idea of retirement. The funding for the coming year is likely to be reduced by two-thirds, from more than 30,000 yuan to 10,000 yuan in income.
"I was greatly affected by this incident, so I have the idea of retiring or changing direction."
In the last National Games, the Karate Federation was involved in unfair selection, and membership was suspended by the Hong Kong Association and Olympic Committee. The audit report was also criticized.
This selection is again controversial.
(Information Picture / Photo by Liang Weiyang)
The president of the air agrees to start discussing and selecting in March, emphasizing fairness, openness, and justice
The President of the Air Corporation admitted that the Secretariat of the Preparatory Committee only began to discuss selection matters with them in mid-March, but emphasized that the entire selection process was open, fair and just, and listed the entire timetable. He also pointed out that the selection of the Second National Youth Games was also The adoption of this mechanism also refers to the fact that there is no consistent international ranking method for sports, so it will not be used as a scoring criterion.
The National Games Preparatory Committee replied that the nomination list of the National Sports Association meets the basic criteria for selection by the Preparatory Committee, but emphasizes that the selection mechanism and arrangements managed by the National Sports Association are not within the scope of the executive committee's authority.
Cheng Ziwen said that the Second Youth Association has less competition in selection and young people participate less in the World Games. Therefore, no similar situation has occurred. I hope that the Association and the Leisure and Cultural Services Department will face up to the defects and loopholes in the selection mechanism.
The Karate Association has again been involved in unfair selection. The last men's "individual" silver medalist and ranked about 30 in the world, Zheng Ziwen, was unsuccessful in the selection scoring system. The representative of the Hong Kong team is the brother of Olympic bronze medalist Liu Mushang, Liu Ming, currently ranked in the world. 104 people.
(Photo by Lu Yiming)
Karate Federation was involved in the unfair selection of the last National Games and was transferred to the current session by more than half of the DQ Executive Committee of the Hong Kong Association. [Pictures] Liu Muchang Karate behind the Olympic bronze medal. Karate developed in Hong Kong. Liu Muchang won the bronze. Residents really want to drive Tokyo Olympics and Karate in Hong Kong｜The rules that can’t be hit all the way are related to the “One Hit Kill” Tokyo Olympics︱Musang Liu won the bronze medal in karate, and he was appointed as the flag bearer at the closing ceremony. Bronze medallion relatives and friends watched the war mother from across the bank and wept with joy
01News
