The Limited Times

Jean-Éric Schoettl: "Yes, the preaching of certain Islamic texts is criminally punishable"

11/10/2023, 7:01:28 PM

Highlights: Jean-Éric Schoettl: "Yes, the preaching of certain Islamic texts is criminally punishable" The conviction in the first instance of the imam of Beaucaire, after he posted on Facebook a hadith with genocidal tones, shows that Islam can come into conflict with the laws of the Republic, analyses the former secretary of the... Author of "Democracy at the peril of the courtrooms" (Gallimard, coll. "Le Débat", 2022).


TRIBUNE - The conviction in the first instance of the imam of Beaucaire, after he posted on Facebook a hadith, a text of the Koranic tradition, with genocidal tones, shows that Islam can come into conflict with the laws of the Republic, analyses the former secretary of the...

Author of "Democracy at the peril of the courtrooms" (Gallimard, coll. "Le Débat", 2022).

Is Islam compatible with the laws of the Republic? To ask the question in such a general way is both provocative and idle. It is also a mixture of orders that secularism has carefully separated. The secular republic should not meddle with religion, just as religion, in a secular republic, should not pretend to govern public affairs.

The recent case of the imam of Beaucaire, Yassin El Himer, leads us to give a partial but topical answer to the vast question of the compatibility between Islam and the Republic, no less than disturbing.

On October 12, the day after Hamas' atrocities in Israel, the imam posted on his Facebook account the hadith to his flock: "You will fight the Jews and get the better of them so that the stone will say: 'O Muslim! Here's a Jew hiding behind me......

This article is for subscribers only. You still have 84% to discover.

Want to read more?

Unlock all items immediately.

TEST FOR €0.99

Already a subscriber? Log