The Limited Times

Now you can see non-English news...

Beverage prices may be given without a deposit


Is the packaging deposit part of the beverage price or not? The European Court of Justice will soon decide this question. A legal opinion shows how the verdict could turn out.

Enlarge image

Empty crates of drinks: do you pay for them - or just the drink they carry?

Photo: Ralf Poller / avanti / IMAGO

According to an opinion of the European Court of Justice (ECJ), the deposit for bottles or glasses does not have to be included in the total price.

Grocers can advertise the price of a product and mark the deposit separately, Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou found in his Opinion in Luxembourg.

A verdict on this question is likely to come in a few months.

The ECJ judges often, but not always, follow the assessment of the experts.

The background is a case before the German Federal Court of Justice (BGH).

The Association of Social Competition wanted to have the question clarified in principle and therefore sued a department store chain based in Kiel.

In an advertising brochure, the latter had printed the prices for drinks and yoghurt in a glass without a deposit surcharge, with the addition »plus.


The association considers this inadmissible.

The price must be given in total.

However, most dealers handle it like the people of Kiel do.

The Advocate General largely followed the grocers' arguments.

The deposit can be refunded to the buyer and is therefore - unlike a tax - not part of the final purchase price.

If the deposit were already included in the price, consumers could make false comparisons between the products, since a deposit is charged for some but not for others.

Depending on the type of packaging, the deposit also varies, which makes a comparison even more difficult.

Recycling incentive could disappear

In addition, the deposit system should be an incentive to buy products where the container is recycled.

However, with an overall price, this environmental aspect could fade into the background for buyers, according to Emiliou.

The ECJ is responsible for the uniform interpretation of European Union law.

Once he has made his decision, the case goes back to the national courts and has an impact on the case law there.


Source: spiegel

All business articles on 2023-02-02

You may like

Business 2023-02-02T12:18:18.832Z

Trends 24h

Business 2023-03-29T05:16:08.312Z
Business 2023-03-28T15:12:46.520Z
Business 2023-03-28T14:18:45.990Z


© Communities 2019 - Privacy

The information on this site is from external sources that are not under our control.
The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation or endorse the views expressed within them.