Social News
Written by: Hu Jiaxin
2020-11-12 21:57
Last update date: 2020-11-12 21:57
A teacher at Keli Primary School hosted by Sik Sik Yuen was cancelled by the Education Bureau because of serious teaching errors.
The Education Bureau cited the teacher's teaching mistakes, including mentioning that "the Opium War was due to the British wanting to eliminate opium", and when describing the papermaking technique among China's four great inventions, it attributed the ancients' purpose of developing paper to "preventing animal extinction."
However, according to a teaching short film produced by the Curriculum Resource Group of the Education Bureau in 2009, it also mentioned that China would engrave important events on the oracle bones during the Yin and Shang dynasties. It is also called "If you catch a tortoise every day to engrave it, wouldn't the tortoise be very fast? Will it be extinct?" The question then brings out the change of the text carrier.
Chen Zhihua, a senior Chinese history teacher, believes that it is not correct to explain the origin of papermaking on environmental reasons, but it is not unreasonable to bring out correct historical facts to students on the spot as a teaching question.
He continued to point out that this time the teacher was immediately "DQ" due to teaching errors, which caused many teachers to discuss and worry. "Is it that you die if you make a serious mistake, and you can't turn around?" He hoped that the bureau could clarify the punishment criteria and order the teacher. Can allay doubts.
The press release issued by the Education Bureau stated that the primary school teachers involved had made serious mistakes in teaching, lacked the ability to serve as teachers, and did not perform due diligence at all. They were incompetent. Therefore, their teacher registration was cancelled in accordance with the Education Ordinance.
The bureau stated that the teacher had many examples of errors in teaching professions, and cited one of them, stating that the teacher "when describing the papermaking among the four great inventions in China, he also described the purpose of the ancients for developing paper as a replacement for turtle shells. , Animal bones, etc. are recorded to "prevent animal extinction"." The bureau described that the teacher's teaching content was obviously seriously wrong, and even "nonsense."
However, the original official textbooks of the Education Bureau had similar historical descriptions.
In 2009, the Curriculum Resource Group of the Education Bureau produced a 15-minute instructional video of "Four Great Inventions in China (Part 1)" to introduce the evolution of China’s papermaking and printing. The host mentioned that there was no paper developed at that time, so it was important Things will be carved on the oracle bones or cast on the tripod.
However, the host raised the question, "If you have to engrave on the tortoise shell every time you write, how many turtles are enough?" "If you catch tortoises every day to engrave, won't the tortoises become extinct soon?" Bring out the evolution of the word carrier.
Chen Zhihua, a senior Chinese history teacher, believes that this time the teacher was immediately "DQ" due to teaching errors, which caused many teachers to discuss and worry. He believed that the Education Bureau should clarify more details.
(Profile picture)
History teacher: Teachers worry that teaching mistakes can be "DQ"
Chen Zhihua, a senior Chinese history teacher, believes that Chinese writing instruments have gradually evolved from oracle bones to paper. After thousands of years, teachers can introduce the history of science and technology and the history of civilization. However, if the purpose of paper research and development is attributed to "preventing animals The environmental reasons for extinction are not correct. "The ancients did not have this concept at that time."
On the contrary, he believes that if the question "prevent animal extinction" is used to arouse students' interest in papermaking, it is not wrong to make immediate corrections; and the video only points out the question that turtles are frequently engraved with tortoises, which may have a chance of extinction. There is no problem.
He said that teachers will inevitably make mistakes in teaching, such as "speaking quickly" the wrong year of historical events, and will make corrections to students when they find out.
However, this time the teacher was immediately "DQ" due to teaching errors, which caused many teachers to discuss and worry. They believed that the Education Bureau should clarify the punishment criteria, such as whether the teachers involved frequently made mistakes in teaching and whether serious mistakes in teaching should be immediately taken To obtain qualifications and "nothing to turn over", etc., so that teachers can relieve their doubts.
The Education Bureau cancels another teacher’s registration Ye Jianyuan: the establishment is chasing after the punishment is out of proportion
The Education Bureau cancels another teacher's registration, accusing it of a serious teaching error, which is known to be a teacher in Keli Primary School
The preaching teacher was nailed Yang Runxiong: Actively follow up and publish the "To eliminate opium" theory can be established as a teacher
The group said that the content of the Opium War was involved in teaching errors. Teachers have left their jobs and worry about school textbook bias
01News
Education Bureau History Chinese History Primary School Education Middle School